Dancing the Two-Step this Simchat Torah

BY RABBI DR. KATRIEL (KENNETH) BRANDER

As we approach Simchat Torah – a day on which we customarily dance – the shadow of October 7’s horrors still lingers. Last year, dancing was difficult. Those who could manage it did so courageously, but in darkness and muted celebration. What about this year? Have things changed? In some ways our lives have remained the same, while in others our outlook has evolved.

As time passes, we are learning resilience in the face of tragedy. Songs about the current reality populate our playlists. Young children coping with their new realities make up short rhymes about Houthis and Iranian missiles. Last year, our children needed to know where the safe rooms were; this year, they want to know if the rooms have wi-fi. We talk more openly about trauma than perhaps at any time in the history of this country. 

Construction around the country is, baruch Hashem, booming, and parking at malls has again become treacherous. We are out shopping for school supplies and the chagim. Fertility rates have reversed course – rather than continuing their decline, they have rebounded and even slightly exceeded previous levels.

And yet, we are never far away from the realities of war. The ongoing pressures have led to struggles with mental health and suicides in the IDF. Parents, children, spouses, students and colleagues are still spending too much time away from family, their studies and their businesses. We still live with the horrific reality of hostages yet to come home, and we face anxiety and uncertainty about what will happen in Gaza or with Iran. 

But we must once again dance on Simchat Torah even if it’s still hard and confusing. Perhaps we need to do the ‘two-step’: dancing forward in one direction while pivoting to acknowledge that we are still living amid a war. We are living in two concurrent realities and must dance in the presence of both. For our light is woven with the darkness of war.

We dance in celebration of our mesorah, inspired by the immense sacrifice of our fellow Jews, including the hostages in Gaza, who maintained their devotion to tradition under unimaginably difficult circumstances. Agam Berger, taken hostage from her base, observed fast days and refused non-kosher meat despite hunger and scarce food. She refused to light fires on Shabbat to cook for her captors, putting her life in even greater peril. We dance in celebration of a Torah so beloved that former hostage Ohad Ben Ami, confined to a six-square-meter cell, recited kiddush and havdalah each week – even without wine.

We dance because of the resilience of our people – those like Yonatan Veinstock, whose burnt Gemara was found in his bombed out tank. During breaks in the fighting, he had been reviewing the sugyot learned at Yeshivat Hesder Beren-Machanaim before suffering injuries that required a double lung replacement. Baruch Hashem, thanks to his and his family’s tenacity as well as the indefatigable perseverance of his medical team, Yonatan is now living a beautiful life with his wife. I look forward to dancing for – and with – him. 

As the war continues, we are also witnessing a growing number of Israelis who do not identify as religious seeking deeper connection to Judaism, and the beauty of different parts of society coming together. I have seen soldiers returning from Gaza or Lebanon asking for help with the words of Birkat haGomel, covering one another’s heads with their hands. I have also observed more women lighting candles on Friday nights and participating in challah baking events.

Rav Soloveitchik once noted that throughout the Hoshanot, the Sukkot hakafot service, we express our relationship with G-d by encircling the bimah where someone holds the Torah scroll – what halacha calls a kinyan hiluch, concretizing our bond with the Torah by walking around the bimah. On Simchat Torah, however, we take the Torah scrolls and carry them as we dance, leaving the bima empty save for the Shechina. In the Boston synagogue where the Rav prayed, the bima on Simchat Torah was roped off to emphasize that it held only the presence of G-d. For the Torah itself is a means to an end – helping us forge our relationship with the Divine.

This year, as we encircle the “empty” bima, I will imagine it not empty at all, but filled with the hundreds of holy souls taken from us since October 7. They too are dancing on the bima, with and around G-d. We are dancing with duality – living in the darkness of war and uncertainty, yet simultaneously drawing strength from perseverance and faith. Together with the Shechina, with the souls on the bima, and those of us in the circle, we will all sing as one, celebrating the eternal nature of our bond. Am Yisrael Chai!

 

Rabbi Dr. Katriel (Kenneth) Brander is President and Rosh HaYeshiva of Ohr Torah Stone, an international network of 30 Religious Zionist institutions committed to illuminating the beauty and relevance of authentic Torah Judaism in the modern world. Prior to making Aliyah, Rabbi Brander was Vice President at Yeshiva University and the senior rabbi of the Boca Raton Synagogue, overseeing its explosive growth from 60 to more than 600 families. (Headshot: Sally Katzin)

© 2026 World Mizrachi

Follow us: