From Tisha B’Av to Tu B’Av: The Sin and the Solution

BY RABBI DORON PEREZ
This year marks the 50th anniversary of arguably the most daring hostage rescue operation in modern history.
On July 4th, 1976 – the 6th of Tammuz, 5736 – the State of Israel carried out Operation Entebbe, later renamed Operation Yonatan, in memory of Yoni (Yonatan) Netanyahu, the older brother of Israel’s Prime Minister and the commander who fell leading the mission. Palestinian and German terrorists had hijacked an Air France flight carrying 248 passengers and diverted it to Entebbe Airport in Uganda. After the non-Israeli and non-Jewish passengers were gradually released, 106 hostages remained – 84 Israelis and Jewish passengers – while the Air France crew courageously stayed behind, refusing to abandon them.
In an extraordinary overnight raid conducted 2,500 miles from Israel, elite commandos from Sayeret Matkal flew to Uganda and rescued 102 of the 106 hostages.
In contrast to that single night’s operation, it would take 853 excruciating days for the last of the 251 hostages – cruelly dragged across the border on that horrific day in October 2023 – to be brought home. January 26th, 2026, marked the first time in almost twelve years that there were, thank G-d, no hostages – alive or deceased – held in Gaza.
I believe that the reason every last hostage returned home from Gaza, and that nearly every hostage returned from Entebbe, can only be explained by an idea I have repeated on numerous occasions since first expressing it at Daniel’s second funeral: we may be the smallest nation, but we are the largest family.
All for one, one for all
At Entebbe, Israel was prepared to sacrifice her finest soldiers, as indeed happened to Yoni Netanyahu, in order to save fellow Jews, Israelis and non-Israelis alike.
In Gaza, almost fifty years later, soldiers and reservists fought not only to defeat our enemies, but to bring their brothers and sisters home. Soldiers endangered their lives in extraction operations where, tragically, some paid with their lives. Time and again, I heard from soldiers how they had searched every corner of Gaza to find our son Daniel and all of the hostages. It felt, they said, as though they were searching for their own brothers and sisters. I also spoke with a number of soldiers involved in the excavation efforts to recover the remains of the last deceased hostage held in Gaza, Ran Gvili. They described the dangers they were willing to endure for the privilege of bringing him home for burial, and of giving his parents, and indeed all of the Jewish people, some measure of closure after more than two years of what may be the most harrowing period in Israel’s history.
They behaved not only as patriots or comrades-in-arms, but as siblings bringing their brother home.
Across the Jewish world, Jews in every corner of the globe lived with the fate of the hostages as if they were their own children. From Jerusalem to Johannesburg, Moscow to Washington, Sydney to New York, Jews everywhere responded with a shared sense of familial love and solidarity. Prayers, mutual anguish, solidarity missions, political advocacy. We became like a single organism, “like one person with one heart.” One family.
Jews, it seems, will always – when push comes to shove – do almost anything to bring our hostages home: from Entebbe to Nachshon Wachsman to Gilad Shalit to the recent war in Gaza. Our enemies have always known this about us, and they exploit what they perceive as our weakness – our love of life and our refusal to abandon our own – by taking hostages and demanding impossible prices for their release.
When one steps back and looks at the sweep of Jewish history, a pattern emerges. Time and again, we will do almost anything – pay exorbitant prices, take enormous risks – to bring every last one home. All for one.
Why? To some, it seems irrational – even irresponsible and reckless.
Until the last hostage: bonds of brotherhood
Why do we do it? The answer, I believe, is not found in geopolitics, patriotism, or military strategy nor in religious doctrine or law. It is found in something more intuitive and primal: the mystery of familial belonging, the bond of brotherhood.
Remarkably, there are two stories of Jewish captives in the Chumash, and in both cases only a single hostage is taken. And in both cases, the rescuers are prepared to sacrifice everything to save that one person.
This goes back to our spiritual DNA, to the very dawn of Jewish history, when the first Jew, our founding father Avraham, was confronted with this very dilemma when his nephew Lot was taken captive.
When Avraham hears that Lot has been captured, the same Lot who had separated from him and chosen to live in the morally corrupt city of Sodom, turning his back on everything Avraham stood for, he does not hesitate for a moment. Avraham risks everything: his life, the lives of all the members of his household, and his entire G-d-given mission for the benefit of humanity. He mobilizes every able-bodied man he has, 318 in all, and launches a daring military attack against the armies of four powerful regional kings.
I have often wondered: why does Avraham not seek counsel from G-d? Why was he prepared to sacrifice his life and his divinely-mandated mission to save his errant nephew? How did he know this was what G-d would want?
The answer, I believe, is embedded in the text itself, in a single word that explains everything. When the Torah tells this story, it does not say that Avraham heard that his nephew had been captured. It says: “And Avraham heard that his brother had been taken captive” (Bereishit 14:14).
There it is. Lot was not merely a sinful, wayward relative. Lot was his brother. The moment Avraham saw Lot through the eyes of brotherhood, there were no more questions to ask – no cost-benefit analysis to perform, no rational threshold beyond which rescue becomes inadvisable, no need to consult anyone, not even G-d. A brother had been taken. You go. That is all. It is written in our hearts with bonds of blood, and no further instruction is required.
The captive maidservant in Arad
The second incident recorded in the Chumash also involves a single captive. The Canaanite king of Arad attacks Israel while they are still in the desert and seizes one prisoner: “And the Canaanite king of Arad who resided in the Negev heard that Israel had arrived by way of the Atarim, and came out to war with Israel and took from them a captive” (Bamidbar 21:1).
The Torah describes the captive in the singular – one hostage. Rashi, citing the opinion of the Sages, identifies the captive not as a person of standing but as a simple maidservant, perhaps the most socially marginal member of the community. And yet the Children of Israel go to war, risking their lives to free her.
Family is family
In a family, no one is expendable. No one is left behind. Every single life, every single member, carries infinite and equal value.
Which father would not dive into raging rapids to try to save his drowning child? Which brother would not charge into a burning building for his sister?
I am not even certain it is halachically permitted to take such extreme risks to one’s own life when the chances of saving another are slim. And yet a parent or sibling would rather die trying than live knowing they could have acted and didn’t. That is the beautiful logic, or illogic, of family. The ties that bind are not written in law books or policy manuals, but in bonds of blood; in the deep, mysterious bonds of heart and soul.
It is this sense of familial connection among Jews, this instinct of brotherhood, that explains the lengths to which we have always been prepared to go for one another in times of need.
The sin and the solution
When brothers turn on each other and betray the ethic of brotherhood, the consequences are catastrophic. The first murder was Kayin killing his brother Hevel. Yosef’s brothers sold him into slavery and left him for dead. The destruction of the Second Beit HaMikdash was brought about precisely by this collapse of brotherhood: sinat chinam, baseless hatred among Jews.
If Tisha B’Av is the day we suffer the consequences of baseless hatred between brothers, then Tu B’Av is the remedy. It is the day on which, across different generations, brothers and sisters came back together, when inter-tribal harmony was restored in Israel. The Sages (Ta’anit 30b) record three such instances: when women were permitted to marry men from any tribe; when the ban on the tribe of Binyamin intermarrying with other tribes – imposed after the terrible sin of the Concubine of Givah – was lifted; and when King Hoshea of the Northern Kingdom removed the guards from the road to Jerusalem, allowing the ten tribes to once again reach the Beit HaMikdash and intermingle with the tribes of Yehuda and Binyamin of the Southern Kingdom.
The heartfelt kinship of brotherhood among Jews in Israel and around the world is what motivated Operation Yonatan in 1976, and what ensured the return of every last hostage from Gaza by 2026.
From Avraham to Arad, from Entebbe to Gaza, the same clarion call rings out – the call of the Jewish family that Avraham first expressed to Lot when tensions arose between their shepherds: “Let there not be strife between me and you… for we are brothers” (Bereishit 13:8).
Rabbi Doron Perez is the Executive Chairman of World Mizrachi.