What is a hero? This timeless question has been answered countless times over the past year, as soldiers and citizens alike have stepped forward, rising to meet the challenges of each day, hour, and moment. These individuals join the ranks of our nation’s heroes – men and women whose courage and selflessness have shaped Am Yisrael. Understanding their sacrifice inspires us to reflect on our capacity for resilience, unity, and action while striving to embody their example.
The Gemara, as with many time-bound mitzvot, explores whether women are obligated in the mitzvah of Chanukah. Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi states: “Women are obligated in the candle of Chanukah as they also were part of the miracle” (Shabbat 23a). While one opinion explains that women, like men, were subjugated and saved, another asserts that women played a central role in bringing about the miracle itself.
The story of Yehudit exemplifies this heroism. According to the Otzer Midrashim, she could not stand idly by as Jewish women were forced to comply with the Greek governor’s morally depraved edicts and her nation faced great peril. At great risk, she exited the gates of Yerushalayim along with her maidservant, praying for a miracle. Disguising her intentions, Yehudit approached the ruler, offering him wine and cheese until he fell asleep. Seizing her moment, she severed his head and brought it back to Yerushalayim. Initially accused of impropriety, she silenced her detractors by displaying the evidence of her act. The community cried out Shema Yisrael, and the Greeks, hearing the triumphant cry and seeing their leader’s demise, fled in terror. Yehudit’s bravery is commemorated in the custom of eating dairy foods during Chanukah and many women refrain from work while the candles burn.
Chana, another Chanukah heroine, demonstrated remarkable spiritual strength. As her seven sons faced torture for refusing to bow to the Greek ruler’s idol, Chana encouraged each of them to remain steadfast in their faith. To her youngest son, who was urged to stoop for the ruler’s ring as an act of idol worship, she declared, “Tell your ancestor Avraham, ‘You bound one son upon an altar, but I bound seven.’” Her profound courage and unwavering faith in Hashem transcended her maternal instinct, inspiring generations with her heroic selfless devotion.
A contemporary perspective offers nuanced insight into heroism. Bill Moyers, a renowned journalist, once interviewed Joseph Campbell, author of The Hero with a Thousand Faces. In their discussion, Moyers asked why so many cultures and stories are centered around the hero archetype. Campbell explained that heroes are individuals who achieve something extraordinary or dedicate themselves to a cause greater than themselves. He described two types of heroic deeds: the physical deed, where the hero performs an act of courage or saves a life, and the spiritual deed, where the hero transcends ordinary human experience and returns with a transformative message.
The heroism of Yehudit closely parallels the construct of the physical deed in John Campbell’s theory – her strength and courage led her to risk her life to confront and eliminate the Greek ruler. Chana exemplifies the concept of the spiritual deed. Her bravery was internal, rooted in faith and devotion, as she inspired her sons to sacrifice their lives for Torah and Hashem. Campbell’s framework resonates deeply with these women’s acts of physical and spiritual courage: a hero is someone who has given their life to something greater than themselves.
The phrase, “בַּיָּמִים הָהֵם, בַּזְּמַן הַזֶּה, in those days, in this time,” bridges past and present, reminding us that the heroism of Chanukah is not confined to history. Just as Yehudit and Chana rose to extraordinary challenges, today we witness soldiers, families, and communities demonstrating unparalleled bravery in the defense of Israel. These modern-day Maccabees remind us that heroism is found not only in great moments of history but also in everyday acts of courage and unity. As we light the menorah, we recognize their sacrifices and are called to reflect on our own roles – to strengthen our communities, support those who stand on the front lines on the battlefield and at home, to ensure that the light of faith burns brightly, בַּזְּמַן הַזֶּה, today.
Rebbetzin Dr. Adina Shmidman is the director of the OU Women’s Initiative. She and her husband Rabbi Avraham Shmidman, are Rabbi and Rebbetzin at the Lower Merion Synagogue in Bala Cynwyd, PA.
