No Jew is Written Off: The Religious Zionist Vision of Rav Mordechai Eliyahu zt”l

BY RABBI ELIE MISCHEL

In 1951, a twenty-one-year-old yeshiva student stood before an Israeli court and explained, with complete composure, why he joined an underground organization that torched cars on Shabbat and butcher shops selling non-kosher meat. “I felt that the Jews have an inferiority complex that causes them to be disrespected by others. I believed that through the underground we could impose Torah living in the state.”1 He was sentenced to ten months in prison.

Thirty-two years later, that same man walked into the Yochanan Ben Zakai Synagogue in the Jewish Quarter of Jerusalem, a hundred meters from where he was born, and was installed as the Rishon L’Tzion, the Sephardic Chief Rabbi of Israel. The young man who tried to impose Torah on the Jewish state by force was now its highest religious authority. 

Rav Mordechai Eliyahu was born in 1929 in Jerusalem’s Jewish Quarter, into an Iraqi rabbinic family of unusual distinction. His father, Rav Salman Eliyahu, was a Kabbalist and disciple of the Ben Ish Chai – Rav Yosef Hayyim of Baghdad, one of the great Sephardic poskim of the nineteenth century. His mother was the Ben Ish Chai’s niece. The Ben Ish Chai’s halachic methodology – integrating halachic literature with Kabbalistic sources – would define Rav Eliyahu’s own approach to halacha for the rest of his life.

Rav Salman died when Mordechai was eleven, leaving the family desperately poor. He sold cooked chickpeas in the street and checked mezuzot to help support his mother, and continued to learn Torah whenever and wherever he could. He eventually made his way to Porat Yosef Yeshiva, where he studied under Rav Ezra Attiya. Over the years, he would study from a remarkably broad range of teachers, including the Chazon Ish, Rav Mordechai Sharabi, Rav Yaakov Mutzafi, Rav Yitzchak Kaduri. In later life, he also cultivated a unique relationship with the Lubavitcher Rebbe.

In 1950, he joined Brit HaKanaim, the “Covenant of the Zealots,” a small underground organization made up mostly of young yeshiva students who believed that secular Israeli policies – particularly efforts to secularize immigrant communities and restrict Torah education – were destroying Jewish religious life from within. They saw themselves as defenders of the Jewish people’s spiritual future.2 Some members crossed serious legal lines, and the group paid the price when the Shin Bet dismantled it in 1951. 

Though he never renounced the group’s goals, he came to recognize that its methods were wrong. Years later, he said, “I admit the way that I went in the past is not appropriate for our generation; not that the Torah has changed, heaven forbid, but rather the way to instill it in the people has changed.”3

What changed most dramatically was his understanding of who secular Israelis actually were. When Rav Elazar Shach described secular Israelis as “pork-eaters and rabbit-eaters,”4 Rav Eliyahu responded sharply: “Even pork-eaters and rabbit-eaters are Jews, and even if all the rabbis decide as Rabbi Shach does, they cannot strip the name ‘Jew’ from any person.”5 

He made this position the subject of a formal article, titled Ein Yehudi Muktzeh,6 in which he argued that no Jew could ever be written off completely. “There are no heretics today. Everyone is simply a poor soul. Everything they do comes from ignorance and lack of knowledge.” The secular Israeli who drove on Shabbat was not a rebel against the Torah, but rather a Jew who was never properly taught about Shabbat. “Even the one who desecrates Shabbat, or eats non-kosher is in favor of there being kosher food and Shabbat.” Underneath the indifference and hostility, he saw “a thirst and a search for something positive.”7

This conviction translated into action. He traveled to secular moshavim and kibbutzim, spoke anywhere he was invited, and refused to wait for people to seek him out. “A rabbi should not sit in his office waiting for people to come and ask him. A rabbi must travel from city to city, from settlement to settlement, from school to school.” He reported that he encountered no hatred in these places, only people who had been led to believe that rabbis looked down on them. And he demanded the same effort from every religious Jew: go to your secular neighbors, learn Torah together, make chavrutot, and reach out person to person. “A drop of light drives away much darkness. Add much more light, all the more so.”8

Defending the diversity of halacha 

At only 30-years-old, Rav Eliyahu was appointed dayan in Be’er Sheva – the youngest in the history of the modern State. He rose steadily through the Jerusalem rabbinical court to the Supreme Rabbinical Court, and in 1983 was elected Rishon L’Tzion, serving alongside Ashkenazic Chief Rabbi Avraham Shapira until 1993.

Writing after Rav Eliyahu’s passing, Rabbi Yosef Zvi Rimon described him as “a combination of a Kabbalist thoroughly versed in Shas and the poskim, and a posek who has a distinguished place in Kabbalah.”9 The Ben Ish Chai, his methodological anchor, drew on both Kabbalistic tradition and the Rema, the great Ashkenazic authority, producing rulings that were consistently stricter than the Shulchan Aruch. This put Rav Eliyahu on a different track from Rav Ovadia Yosef, who held that Sephardic practice follows the Shulchan Aruch alone and had little patience for Kabbalistic stringencies.

The practical consequences of this divide have implications across the entire range of halacha. Take one example: making coffee on Shabbat. Rav Ovadia permitted pouring directly from a kettle – a kli rishon, or primary vessel – over the coffee grounds. Rav Eliyahu required that the water first be poured into a kli sheni, a secondary vessel, before being used, following the Ben Ish Chai, who holds, like the Rema, that a kli rishon continues to cook whatever it contacts.

Their larger disagreement ran deeper than any individual ruling. Rav Ovadia sought to consolidate all Sephardic practice into a single unified “Israeli Sephardic” halacha based on the Shulchan Aruch and his own rulings. Rav Eliyahu resisted this systematically. The Iraqi tradition, the Yemenite tradition, the Moroccan tradition – each had its own authorities, its own customs, its own long and holy tradition. He published his own siddur, Qol Eliyahu, as a direct counter to Rav Ovadia’s project. It was a declaration that the Ben Ish Chai is the final authority for the Iraqi community, and that no unification project has the right to erase what centuries of tradition had built.

In the introduction to his commentary on the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch, he explained his thinking: “Especially in our generation, which is a ‘time of gathering the harvest,’ and Torah scholars have increased from all the communities, and there is love and brotherhood among them – therefore every Torah scholar must know all the customs of all the communities.” This was his vision of what the ingathering of the exiles demanded of a rabbi: “In every community there are people from different communities who learn and pray together and live as one. A teacher in such a community cannot teach from standard halachic books in a general way, because he may end up teaching a halacha that is correct for one community, while members of another community must practice differently.”10 For Rav Eliyahu, the diversity of Jewish tradition was not a problem to be solved, but rather a treasure to be honored.

For all the principled distance between him and Rav Ovadia, their personal bond was something else entirely. About ten years before Rav Eliyahu’s passing, Rav Ovadia personally appeared at his door on Purim morning, carrying mishloach manot, unannounced and without his usual entourage. When Rav Eliyahu opened the door and saw who was standing there, he wept.11

A Religious Zionist gadol

Rav Eliyahu stood in the broad orbit of Rav Kook’s Religious Zionism. He believed that “our generation is the generation of redemption,” saw the return of Am Yisrael to Eretz Yisrael and the establishment of the State as part of that process, and shared the activist conviction that Jews must settle every part of the Land. But he was not a Rav Kook disciple in any systematic sense. He did not build a philosophical theology of redemption. His worldview was more instinctive than ideological, rooted in the Sephardic tradition that the Land, the people, and the Torah are inherently holy, and that a rabbi’s job is to respond to the reality G-d places before him. 

A beautiful expression of this theology was the L’shem Yichud he composed for IDF soldiers before battle. The L’shem Yichud is a Kabbalistic declaration of intent, recited before a mitzvah to unify the act with its divine purpose. Rav Eliyahu wrote one for soldiers, framing military service as the fulfillment of three Torah commandments: “I am hereby prepared to fulfill the positive Torah commandment to conquer the Land and dwell in it, as written in the Torah: ‘And you shall possess it and dwell in it’; and the commandment of loving Israel, as it is written: ‘You shall love your neighbor as yourself’; and the commandment to protect and save Jews, as it is written: ‘You shall not stand idly by the blood of your neighbor.’”12 A soldier reciting these words before entering combat understands that he is more than a soldier in the IDF. He is a soldier of G-d Himself. 

Rav Eliyahu’s opposition to the Oslo Accords, and to any surrender of the Land of Israel, was absolute and uncompromising. “No one, even the Prime Minister, has the right to cede even one granule of the Land of Israel! The Holy One, blessed be He, gave it to us!”13 He also rejected the phrase “returning territories,” which was casually used by many Israeli politicians, journalists, and diplomats: “We expressed a firm position as the Chief Rabbinate against ‘returning territories.’ The expression ‘returning’ is out of place. Whoever uses this term is as if acknowledging that he is returning something that belongs to someone else. This belongs to us. Others took it from us. When we retook the territories in 5727 [1967] – that was the true ‘return.’”14 After Beit Lechem and Chevron were transferred to the Palestinian Authority under Oslo, he ruled that one who drives by these cities is obligated to tear kri’ah, as one does at the death of a close relative.15

His most fraught public battle was with Rav Ovadia Yosef over the Oslo Accords. Rav Ovadia ruled that surrendering land was not only permitted but potentially required. If security experts assured him it would save Jewish lives, then pikuach nefesh, the obligation to preserve life, overrode the sanctity of the Land. Rav Eliyahu believed that Rav Ovadia’s position was built on false premises, that Rav Ovadia had been misled by the politicians and security officials around him about what the Oslo Accords would actually produce. He met with Rav Ovadia in person to tell him so, but Rav Ovadia would not be moved. Shas stayed in the coalition and gave the Rabin government the political support it needed to push the process forward. Years later, Rav Eliyahu was measured in how he assigned blame: “Had they revealed the truth to him at the time of the Oslo Accords, everything would have been different. At the time, people around him misled him.”16 

What followed, of course, was not peace. The Oslo Accords unleashed a wave of suicide bombings and terror attacks that killed hundreds of Israelis and left thousands of families shattered. “Land for peace” turned out to be “Land for slaughter” – and Rav Eliyahu saw it coming.

Beyond the public positions

For all the fierceness of his public positions, those who knew Rav Eliyahu personally encountered a different dimension of the man. In 1957, on his first day as a dayan in Be’er Sheva, he noticed a woman standing outside the courthouse, praying from a small book of Tehillim. She was there the next day, and the day after. He finally sent the beit din’s secretary to bring her inside.

She was a recent immigrant from Morocco who had made Aliyah alone. A week after her wedding, at the end of the sheva brachot, her husband, a taxi driver, was killed in a crash. His body was never found. Without a body, the rabbinical courts in Morocco had refused to declare him dead, leaving her an agunah – a chained woman, unable to remarry. She came to Israel with one hope: that what the courts of Morocco could not do, the courts of Israel would. 

Rav Eliyahu asked her why she remained outside praying and didn’t come into the beit din to speak with the judges. Her answer was simple: “Who are you? I pray to G-d, not to you!”

Rav Eliyahu took her papers and made her case his own. He traveled to the Baba Sali in Netivot, who directed him to his brother, the Baba Haki in Ramle, who told him there were only two Jewish burial officials, kavranim, in all of Morocco, and that both had since immigrated to Israel. One lived in Dimona, the other in Kiryat Ata. Rav Eliyahu headed to Dimona first, only to find the man’s family sitting shiva. He had died just a few days earlier. Rav Eliyahu went in anyway and offered words of Torah and comfort to the mourners. When he explained why he had come, a man in the room stood up. He was the second kavran. “I know that story. I was the one who buried the taxi driver.” Rav Eliyahu brought him to testify before the beit din in Be’er Sheva, and the woman was freed.

“This is the power of prayer,” Rav Eliyahu said afterward. “Both hers and mine.”17 But the truth is that this story only happened because, on his very first day on the job, he looked up from his desk, noticed someone standing outside – and asked who she was.

In the end, the young man who went to prison for trying to impose Torah on the Jewish state became the rabbi who understood that Torah cannot be forced – only taught and lived, one person at a time, with patience and love. When he passed away on the 25th of Sivan, 5770 (2010), at the age of 81, over one hundred thousand people accompanied him to his burial on Har HaMenuchot. He loved his people with all his heart – and they loved him in return.

1 Rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu: Israel’s Sephardi Chief Rabbi who was orthodox in his religion and radical in his politics, July 16, 2010, Independent, www.independent.co.uk/news/obituaries/rabbi-mordechai-eliyahu-israel-rsquo-s-sephardi-chief-rabbi-who-was-orthodox-in-his-religion-and-radical-in-his-politics-2027760.html

2 Rabbi Eliyahu and the Organization Brit HaKanaim, Orot Israel College, https://orot.ac.il/הרב–אליהו–זצל–וארגון–ברית–הקנאים.  Accessed 9 Apr 2026.

3 See Doresh Tov Le’amo, Part 1, edited by Rabbi Shmuel Zafrany, Beit Midrash LeRabbanim.

4 Netta Schramm, A Radicalization of Haredi Fatalist Theology: Rabbi E.M.M. Shach’s Public Addresses, 1988–1991, Journal of Modern Jewish Studies (October 1, 2025), https://doi.org/10.1080/14725886.2025.2546593.

5 HaRabbanut HaRashit LeYisrael, Vol. 3, p. 1469, activity diary of the Chief Rabbinate, 29 Nissan 5750. See also the response of Rabbi Shlomo Goren in Iturei Kohanim 65, Av 5750, 39.

6 Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, Ein Yehudi Muktzeh, Mayanei Hayeshuah, issue 358.

7 Interview in HaTzofeh, Yom HaAtzmaut supplement, 5747, by Yonah Cohen.

8 Interview in Mayanei Hayeshuah, before the 5766 elections.

9 Rabbi Yosef Zvi Rimon, “On the Rulings of Rabbi Eliyahu,” Kipa News, June 8, 2010.

10 Rav Mordechai Eliyahu, Introduction to his commentary on the Kitzur Shulchan Aruch.

11 Mishloach Manot from Rav Ovadia, zt”l, to Rav Eliyahu, zt”l, on Purim, HaMachon le-Horaaat Halacha B’Tzibur (HSE), December 18, 2022, https://hse.org.il/lessons/משלוח–מנות–מהרב–עובדיה–זצוקל–לרב–אליהו-2/.

12 Rav Shmuel Eliyahu, Avihem shel Yisrael (2010), 106.

13 Rabbis Union: No One Has the Right to Give Away the Land, Israel National News, June 24, 2003, www.israelnationalnews.com/news/45568.

14 Mayanei Hayeshuah, issue 165, Tishrei 5765.

15 Interview in Yediot Acharonot, 7 Days supplement, 29 Elul 5757, by Amos Nevo.

16 Iturei Kohanim 189, Av 5760.

17 Yerachmiel Tilles, The Power of Prayer, Chabad, www.chabad.org/kabbalah/article_cdo/aid/1236905/jewish/The-Power-of-Prayer.htm

Rabbi Elie Mischel is the Editor of HaMizrachi magazine and the author of The War Against the Bible: Ishmael, Esau and Israel at the End Times (2024).

© 2026 World Mizrachi

Follow us: