Veiled Truths: Unpacking the Role of Secrecy in Megillat Esther

BY DR. NECHAMA PRICE
Secrecy is a central theme in Megillat Esther. By naming the book after its heroine (whose true name is Hadassah), Esther (derived from the word סתר, secret) accentuates secrecy as a main theme of the book. Throughout the narrative, Esther is secretive of her identity and her relationship to Mordechai as well as her intentions behind hosting the King at two parties. What is behind her secretiveness?
A quick look through Tanach reveals many reasons to keep a secret, especially about one’s identity. Twice in Bereishit, Sarah maintains an alias (Avraham’s sister), rather than her true identity (Avraham’s wife) to save her husband’s life. She and Avraham feared that if the Egyptians knew her true role, they might harm him to get to her. At least at face value, the secrecy was for his safety and protection.
The similarities between this story and ours could provide us with insight into Esther’s secretive nature. Sarah and Esther are both described as beautiful women (Bereishit 12:11, Esther 2:7), taken for marriage against their will by a foreign monarch (Bereishit 12:15, Esther 2:8), and hide their true identities from the monarch. With this as backdrop, we might suggest that Esther might have modeled her behavior after Sarah, and for a comparable reason – to protect Mordechai. Mordechai, the Court Jew, knew of many enemies who wished to harm the Jews. In that regard, it is reasonable that Mordechai kept his own Jewish identity a secret to avoid danger to his life. Only after Haman discovers Mordechai’s Jewish identity (Esther 3:4–6), are all the Jewish people in danger.
The secrecy of Esther, when viewed through the prism of Sarah and Avraham, highlights the importance of secrecy in helping someone else. However, other stories from the Navi highlight a different dimension to secrecy – protecting oneself.
One example of using secrets as a form of self-preservation is the story of Shimshon, the Judge. His most unique secret is the ‘magical’ powers of his uncut hair; it gives him incredible strength. While the Plishtim are unaware of his secret, his hair is left untouched and Shimshon is safe. As soon as he tells Delilah about the source of his strength, she cuts off his hair and the Plishtim capture him.
This example could offer insights for understanding the secrets of Esther. Esther is in a precarious situation, separated from the rest of the Jewish nation, and taken by the King of a foreign nation. Knowing how whimsically King Achashveirosh kills people in his lands (such as his first Queen, Vashti), Esther feared for her life (see Ibn Ezra 2:10). Therefore, Esther realizes she must hide her Jewish identity.
A third possibility might be that Esther hid her identity to allow for the possibility of her eventual selection as Queen, a position that could enable her to protect the destiny of the Jewish people (see Ralbag 2:10). Similar to David, who pretends to be an ally of King Achish, who promises to help fight Shaul and the Jewish people (Shmuel I 29) when David was masking his true intention of saving Shaul and the Jewish people.
Similarly, Esther sought to be Queen, not just for her own prestige, but to help the Jewish people through serving in a position of influence. For that matter, many Jewish leaders in Tanach, including Yosef and Daniel, serve the Jewish people by being in the palace of the (non-Jewish) monarch. Yosef retains his identity, revealing it only to help his family during a famine to avoid starvation. So too, Esther reveals her identity to save the Jewish people from destruction at the hands of Haman.
All these other instances of secrecy in Tanach add dimensions of understanding to Esther’s quest to maintain a private identity. From Esther’s helping Mordechai, to her helping herself, to her helping the Jewish people, we have seen how secrecy can support her key objectives, thereby offering us added meaning to the Megillah and inspire us to find our own tools to enable our own participation in the greater Jewish story.
Dr. Nechama Price is the Director of the Graduate Program in Advanced Talmud and Tanach Studies at Yeshiva University, Senior Lecturer of Bible and Jewish Studies at Stern College for Women, and serves as Yoetzet Halacha of Teaneck, Englewood, Tenafly, West Orange, Livingston, and Long Branch NJ.